Skip to content
Court Decisions

Hanlon v. Campbell: NRA and GOAL Challenge Massachusetts Assault-Style Firearms Ban

Hanlon v. Campbell is a federal Second Amendment challenge to Massachusetts' ban on assault-style firearms filed by the National Rifle Association, the Gun Owners' Action League (GOAL), Pioneer Valley Arms, and four individual plaintiffs on August 21, 2025, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts.[1]

Plaintiffs

The complaint describes the four individual plaintiffs as Massachusetts residents with valid Licenses to Carry who are not prohibited from purchasing or possessing firearms under state or federal law.

  • Peter Hanlon, a retired Captain in the Massachusetts Environmental Police
  • David Worman, an orthopedic surgeon
  • Nancy Trehub, a retired prosecutor
  • Jeffrey Sacks, an oral and maxillofacial surgeon

The organizational plaintiffs are the NRA, GOAL, and Pioneer Valley Arms, a licensed Massachusetts firearms dealer.

What Is Being Challenged

Chapter 135 of the Acts of 2024[2] broadened the pre-existing assault weapons ban by replacing the "assault weapon" definition with the wider "assault-style firearm" category, including feature-based tests and a copy-or-duplicate test based on internal components or receivers. The law also requires the Secretary of Public Safety and Security to publish a roster of assault-style firearms online at least three times a year, and the Secretary may amend any roster on the Secretary's own initiative.

The plaintiffs argue that the ban deprives law-abiding citizens of their Second Amendment right to keep and bear firearms that are in common use for lawful purposes across the United States, including numerous makes and models of semiautomatic rifles, shotguns, and handguns.

Legal Theory

The First Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the Commonwealth in Worman v. Healey (2019), a challenge to the earlier assault weapon and large-capacity magazine law, and affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction in Capen v. Campbell (2025).

Relationship to Capen v. Campbell

In April 2025, the First Circuit decided Capen v. Campbell, affirming the denial of a preliminary injunction against an earlier challenge to the Massachusetts assault weapons ban.[4] Hanlon was filed later and specifically targeted the Chapter 135 version of the ban. In October 2025, the district court consolidated Hanlon into the lead Capen docket. The Hanlon docket records the order granting consolidation on October 17, 2025.[5]

SCOTUS Context

On June 30, 2026, the Supreme Court granted certiorari in and consolidated two related assault weapons cases from other circuits, Grant v. Higgins (No. 25-566), challenging Connecticut's ban, and Viramontes v. Cook County (No. 25-238), challenging the Cook County, Illinois ban. The consolidated cases concern whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee the right to possess AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles, with oral argument scheduled for December 2, 2026.[9]

Current Status

On July 9, 2026, the district court granted a joint motion to stay the consolidated Capen/Hanlon proceeding. The court canceled the July 10 status conference and directed counsel to notify the clerk when they are ready for the next status conference.[6]

Note: Hanlon is a district-court case consolidated into Capen.

Practical Impact

The Massachusetts assault-style firearms ban remains in full effect. The pendency of Hanlon does not create any exception to current law. Residents must continue to comply with the Chapter 135 framework unless and until a court issues an injunction or final ruling to the contrary.

Related Appellate Decisions

The First Circuit's later Recchia decision affirmed dismissal of a facial challenge but did not decide an unpreserved magazine argument or other unraised arguments.[7] The en banc Third Circuit's contrary 2026 decision concerning New Jersey restrictions is not binding in Massachusetts.[8]