Skip to content
Court Decisions

Commonwealth v. Thomson: SJC Upholds the Under-21 LTC Requirement

LTCChapter 135Bruen

Commonwealth v. Thomson, SJC-13856, was decided on October 20, 2026. The Supreme Judicial Court affirmed Thomson's conviction for carrying a firearm without a license and held that the licensing age restriction, which keeps persons under twenty-one from obtaining a license to carry, is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. The court decided the facial challenge and did not reach the as-applied challenge, because Thomson had never applied for a license.[7]

Background

Section 131(d)[2] bars issuance of an LTC to an applicant under age 21. The current text of Section 131(d), without the former clause numbering, allows a lawful resident 21 years of age or older residing within the licensing authority's jurisdiction, a law enforcement officer employed by that authority, or a person residing in an area of exclusive federal jurisdiction within a city or town to apply. The Supreme Judicial Court held that Thomson, who did not apply for a firearms license, had standing to raise a facial challenge to the age restriction but not an as-applied challenge, because he had neither applied for a license nor shown that age alone would have kept him from one. The court left open whether a future defendant could show that applying would have been futile.[7]

The Constitutional Argument

When the Second Amendment's plain text covers a person's conduct, Bruen requires the government to show that a firearms regulation is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.[3]

The court applied that test and concluded that restricting firearm possession by those deemed too young to handle firearms safely outside supervised settings is consistent with the nation's regulatory tradition. It compared the current Massachusetts scheme for minors with the historical regulation of firearms by minors and found the two strongly analogous, so the licensing age restriction stands.[7]

How the SJC Answered the Questions

  • Section 131(d), which prevents a person under age 21 from obtaining an LTC, is not facially unconstitutional under the Second Amendment.
  • A defendant who never applied for a license may raise a facial challenge to the age restriction. An as-applied challenge requires having applied for and been denied a license, and Thomson did not show that age alone would have barred him.

Justice Kafker, joined by Justice Wendlandt, concurred in part and dissented in part. They agreed that Thomson could bring a facial challenge but would have remanded the case for further briefing and expert historical evidence before deciding the historical analogy.[7]

September 2026 Federal Development

A separate federal development is the September 17, 2026 Office of Legal Counsel memorandum on handgun sales to adults aged 18 to 20. The memorandum concludes that 18 U.S.C. Section 922(b)(1) and (c)(1) may not be enforced to impose criminal penalties on dealers selling handguns to otherwise law-abiding adults in that age range. This is a federal executive legal opinion. It does not decide Thomson's Massachusetts case.[6]

Potential Impact

Current status: The statutory age-21 minimum for a license to carry remains in effect. The SJC upheld it on October 20, 2026.